2 item(s) · mean composite 0.7346 → 0.7298
Halted. the mean composite fell from 0.7346 to 0.7298 over the items this run touched. The loop stops rather than continuing to the next batch.
| Item | Why it was queued | What changed | Verdict before | Verdict after | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
w-writing-023 | Two reviewers independently found the stem does not describe what the item tests: it asks which choice conforms to the conventions of Standard English, and all four choices are grammatically valid adjectives in the blank, so the only discriminator is meaning. Either the stem should ask for the most logical and precise word, or the choices should differ by convention rather than by sense. | The stem now uses the digital SAT's Words in Context wording in place of the Standard English Conventions wording, and the passage, options and key (B) are unchanged. | claude_review | claude_review | revised |
l-writing-understudy-1 | Same fault: a conventions stem over four derivational forms of one root — exhaustive, exhausting, exhaustible, exhausted — that are all grammatical in the slot and separate only by meaning. Its twin l-writing-understudy-1-twin carries the identical text and needs the same repair once this one is settled. | The stem now uses the digital SAT Words in Context wording in place of the Standard English conventions wording; the passage, options and key stay the same. | claude_review | claude_review | revised |